2010/09/11

The Wheel: From Mobility to Connectivity


The automotive experience is undergoing rapid change. Having essentially evolved into a local area network of computers on wheels, the automobile is now poised to become an Internet node. One kind of intelligent transportation system (ITS) – known as the Connected Vehicle – based on 4G networks will provide new levels of traveler services, convenient payment services, real-time safety features, low-cost infotainment, and new types of social computing applications. In aggregate these will serve to optimize mobility, reduce congestion, make driving safer, healthier and more enjoyable, and make payment for road use, parking and insurance fairer and more convenient.

Skymeter's contribution to the Connected Vehicle consists of private and anonymous payment services based on Financial-grade GPS (FGPS) applications. These services will permit drivers to pay only for the insurance they need by paying per mile or kilometer traveled, only for the parking they occupy by paying by the minute, and only for the roads they use by replacing fuel, registration and property taxes with time-distance-and-place fees, allowing lower rates for off-peak driving.

Paying only for what we use is not only fairer to the consumer of roads, parking and insurance, but has the powerful effect of putting more control over the cost of mobility into the hands of the driver. How often have you sat in congestion on a roadway burning more in fuel and fuel tax than you would have if the road were uncongested? How often have you returned to your parked car with money still on the meter – or worse, how often have you returned a few minutes late to be greeted by a $25 or $40 parking fine? How often have you taken transit, a shared ride, a sick day, or a week’s vacation but paid your automotive insurance anyway? Have you ever parked your Smart Car beside a Cadillac Escalade only to pay exactly the same parking fee?

Road authorities say they need more money while motorists say they pay too much in fuel taxes. Insurers want to raise rates but motorists say insurance costs too much. Parking fees continues to climb while drivers cruise to find cheap spots.  We say it is expensive to drive, but the problem is we pay the wrong way.  We pay for roads by the tank full, insurance by the year, and if you can rationalize all the ways you pay (and don’t pay) for parking you deserve the Nobel in micro-economics.

Connectivity will help alleviate this mobility problem in three ways. Strong connectivity is important for fixing how we pay for mobility, enabling fairer and more transparent ways to pay only for what we use. Connectivity enables the information we need to choose less congested routes and times, to find parking spots and without circling and hunting. Most importantly, connectivity enables the network effect of dozens of other applications related to safety, traveler services, and infotainment that provide motivation for the innovation and markets that will drive the costs of delivering payment services down to 2% or 3%  – a rate that closer to the collection of fuel taxes (1%) than to the current collection costs of insurance, tolls and parking fees (10%-70%).

What we are about to see is that the Connected Vehicle will provide a critical platform for correcting the key economic problem of wrong-payment for mobility – a problem that gives rise to increasing funding unsustainability and congestion.

2010/09/10

Dialogue Mapping and Congestion

I have mentioned, earlier, “Wicked Problems” as a thought paradigm useful in thinking about congestion, road-pricing and the use of road-use metering for allocating road use fees, in this blog over the past months.  Here, here and here.

We are often called to address these kinds of problems in debates, studies or academic conferences.

This talks about the failure of conferences for advancing solutions for really entrenched problems. This says conferences about congestion and road funding, however necessary, may not produce sustainable results soon enough.

This talks about a powerful way to reach a rational consensus about a problem before attempting to derive solutions. This says that we may not be able to reach a shared understanding of the problem if we continue business as usual.

2010/08/29

No New Math from China Traffic Jam


This week provided another opportunity to review the state of progress of demand management for roadway traffic. A spectacular traffic jam outside of Beijing attracted world attention, likely only because it has lasted several days, instead of the more usual hour or two that we now frequently enjoy as a respite from our families while listening to our favorite music.

A WSJ article
by Carl Bialik (2010.08.28), The Inconvenient Truth About Traffic Math: Progress Is Slow, opens with “there is absolutely no way congestion can stop increasing” then hauls out a stack of miserable statistics such as “peak-hour trips now average 25% longer than non-peak hour trips, up from 9% longer 25 years earlier”.

Several solution approaches are mentioned, then criticized as ineffective (“tools [such as ramp metering] shaved an average of about three minutes of travel time for each rush-hour commuter, each week”) or rejected outright (“adding roads … lead[s] to more travel, because of an effect … describe[d] as triple convergence. Many drivers who had shifted their trips to off-peak hours, or to different roads, or to public transit, resume their previous pattern and converge onto the new highway”).

Instead, we are “working to spread traffic out more evenly” (which we were told a paragraph before will save me a whopping 3 minutes per week).

The rest of the article completes a litany of disturbing stats and limp solutions – solutions we already know are growing in cost and diminishing in effectiveness. Ominous in its expense and limited effectiveness will be to “merge data from 60 million devices to detect patterns and build a prediction engine…to predict traffic accurately within 20 minutes, at 80% reliability.”

The Montague Street Flyover
Another will “weave together information about multiple modes of transportation, including road and rail, then attempt to shift traffic accordingly [by using] such information to tell drivers, via electronic roadway signs, how long it will take to get to a popular destination by different routes.” Such approaches are intended to “get a lot more use out of our existing transportation infrastructure.”

Well, very little, actually. We know well that these measures all have minor impacts, like the earlier 3-minute-per-week effect. Similar to attempting to cure Alzheimer’s with Ginkgo Biloba, these impacts are swamped by the growth in vehicle miles traveled as populations grow, accumulate wealth, buy cars, abandon transit, and spread out. Cumulatively, all of our increasingly complex smoothing tools and sanding tricks provide only diminishing returns in congestion abatement.

And we all know this.

There is one tool that has proven the exception: road pricing. Done correctly, as in Stockholm, Singapore or on the SR-91, it produces an initial 15-25% traffic reduction, which can then be sustained with market pricing.

So what’s new? Nothing, really. Every one of the people quoted by Bialik in his Times article knows, studies, writes about or sells road pricing as a solution to the problem. So, why no mention of the only known sustainable solution? WSJ editorial policy? Bialik doesn’t like the idea? The solution just slipped everyone’s mind when interviewed by Bialik?

Why do we persist in hoping and praying like this? “Oh Great Transportation Fairy, we pour out our hearts that you will grant us our birth-right of infinite road space. We know you do not listen, but we beseech you anyway.”

As my mother often told me: “The Transportation Fairy helps those who help themselves.”, but as Bialik documents, rather than help ourselves we seem satisfied praying to some pretty minor saints.


2010/08/12

We need a new ready-made collection platform for road fees

One of the largest differences between collecting fuel taxes and collecting road-use taxes (and this plays very much against the business of collecting road-use taxes) is that a century ago there was a convenient measurement node and collection platform already in place (fuel distributors).  Government(s) merely had to tap into an existing infrastructure.  Relative to any of the current proposed approaches to collecting for road use from each vehicle (RFID/DSRC, GPS, Cellular, Camera, OBD, Odometer, Vignette), collecting at several hundred fuel distribution nodes is smart, easy and cheap.

Making the critically important shift from fuel-consumption tax to road-consumption tax has almost everything stacked against it except that it would (if priced correctly) solve many of our surface transportation problems (funding, congestion, emissions, oil dependence). The problem with all the proposed replacement collection methods is their business execution model: build an elaborate, dedicated, complex, confusing, and expensive infrastructure that is subject to greater user resistance and mischief, to collect a few dollars a week from each vehicle – a terribly small amount for such a complex operation.

This is why the economically inefficient fuel tax is preferred. This is why even less efficient sales taxes are preferred. This is why property taxation is preferred and heavily used. And this is why, in the United States, we are currently back-filling the fuel tax out of the General Fund. From the simple business of finding an affordable assessment and collection mechanism pretty much anything other than metering each vehicle is a more expedient business to administer.

If there was a device already in each vehicle – a reliable device that had another, highly desired, indispensable purpose, i.e., a purpose comparable in importance as having fuel in your tank – such a device could carry an embedded road-use meter and become the collection platform for the replacement of the fuel tax.

We already know several ways to make such devices.  What we are missing is a way to make it have a highly desirable and indispensable purpose. We are missing a free, pre-existing collection platform model to rival the fuel distribution business model that Governments so easily exploited over the past century. This is why building a new, dedicated tax-collection infrastructure that reaches into every vehicle is wrong-headed. And this is why promoting telematics systems for safety, convenience, traveler services, parking payment, PAYD insurance and infotainment – systems that can carry road-use metering functionality for little or no marginal cost – should be the first order.

Such systems can be made desirable, useful, reliable and nearly self-enforceable.  They can make our roads safer, our drives more pleasant, our trip more efficient, our roads less congested and save almost all of us money.  Much more importantly – for matters of funding, demand management, emissions management and oil dependence – such systems can provide the basis for private enterprise to offer profitable and competitive services, just as fuel distributors already offered profitable and competitive services a century ago.

If markets for telematics-based parking and insurance metering, for safety systems, for traveler services and for infotainment were nurtured, standardized, encouraged and in some cases (insurance, parking) regulated or legislated in newer and smarter ways, private enterprise would build the telematics platform governments need to replace the cheap, convenient collection platform afforded by the fuel distributors over a hundred years ago.

This idea should hardly be surprising.  We have been in the Information Age for some decades. Automotive telematics is an information technology. We have ignored the obvious for too long. A private, for-profit telematics platform with numerous desired driver-service applications can be exploited to avoid system operational costs of road tolling, using the same business thinking that governments used to exploit the fuel distribution system a century ago.

2010/08/03

Kant, Morality, Traffic and Big Brother


I have spent seven years (more like 45 man-years if you count the whole team) developing technology for anonymous metering of road use so that governments can rescue our failing surface transport systems by replacing the fuel tax with road-pricing that is a lot more private than the current tolling technologies such as E-ZPass or SunPass.

My started a company to do that because I am a privacy freak and knowing that we need to move to pay-by-road-use instead pay-by-fuel-tax or pay-by-property-tax, I wished to have nothing to do with being ‘tracked’. I also knew that privacy would become one of the barriers to solving the “wicked problem” of congestion. There are several other reasons for our ‘acceptance-by-design work’, but two ideas are enough for one blog.

Now it turns out that my company’s work is not only good for transportation funding, demand management, reducing emissions, and your privacy, but now it seems it is also good for your moral character.

Emrys Westacott, Professor of Philosophy at Alfred University, asks Does Surveillance Make Us Morally Better. Turns out surveillance may be better for society in some cases (such as traffic surveillance for speeding or drunk driving), but it is not necessarily good for your personal moral development, such as a parent strapping a webcam onto the cookie jar.

I’m sure he’d come down on the side of absolutely privacy of road use. Read his article, and see why. Makes those seven long years of hard work worthwhile…

2010/07/31

Chipping away at the fuel tax

In July 2010 UK Transport Secretary, Philip Hammond, confirmed that the ‘Plug-In Car Grant’, designed to stimulate demand for low carbon vehicles, will go ahead from January 2011.

Parsing this sentence, repeated in many news articles, you might suppose this program is about greening the fleet. But if you read the majority of the first 20 Google hits for ‘plug in car grant’ you would see it is more about economic stimulation for the auto-industry.  The low-carbon part is the perfect excuse for a subsidy.

An article at puregreencars.com was clear despite its name: “Carmakers had been putting pressure on the new government to announce the electric car subsidy and had warned the UK would not be attractive for new technology auto investment without it.”  No handout, no investment.

If you have read here before, you know well that fuel tax, as a mechanism to fund roads, is unsustainable, and that all programming to move us into vehicles that directly use less hydrocarbons further endanger that funding source.

Notice that the UK Government has in the past been unable to execute its oft-touted national road-pricing program, but is now prepared to take tax dollars from somewhere to subsidize the purchase of cars (albeit clean ones) hence reducing the tax base needed to build, repair and operate the roads that these new, greener cars will use. Notice that they are not paying people to take transit, bike, or move closer to work, but they are using tax money to pump up an industry that can only cause congestion levels to increase.

Drivers prefer the autonomy, convenience, privacy, and timesaving of a car. It is very hard to transition people out of cars or to move domiciles for the guilt of a few pounds of carbon that they cannot see except in the abstract. If you can subsidize switching costs, a lot of people will elect to drive a cleaner car. But why not do this with differential road-pricing rather than cash handouts? You could start voluntarily and immediately, as it turns out.

I am all for government programming to nudge us in the right direction, however, the problem is that if the car user is being encouraged with direct subsidies, he is encouraged to drive more. The resting state of a world of heavily subsidized, 100% green, single-occupant vehicles is 24-hour total gridlock.

Green-at-all-costs needs slightly more thought than this.

2010/07/19

Tolling Scofflaws - 1859

Canadians have a venerable history of disdain for road tolls, so that the spoiled and entitled commenters that whine and threaten at the end of every Toronto newspaper article about tolling are hardly equipped with novel thoughts.  Here are a couple of Krieghoffs from 150 years ago. According to the Art Gallery of Ontario (AGO), Cornelius Krieghoff apparently came down on the side of the scofflaws and perhaps admired them. In these depictions they seem to be drinking while driving, as well.  So not much has changed, although these fellows would likely be driving three separate SUVs if they were alive today.
If you click-in and study these two paintings carefully, you can see that Kreighoff took some trouble to look at the tolling scofflaw problem from two different angles, but unfortunately came to the same conclusion.

2010/06/24

Governments can’t toll roads

We cannot solve the social and political barriers to nationwide road tolling using the kind of thinking common to Departments of Transportation over the past decade.

The progress of long-sought nation-wide tolling programs is abysmal. Austria, Switzerland, Germany, and Slovakia have achieved this for heavy-goods vehicles only and generally only on highways. This meager outcome – about one every two years – after a decade of planning and development has been made possible for a combination of reasons: commercial operators can arrange a measure of financial recovery, a modicum of trust in the reasonable argument that this must be done to fund roads, technocratic vision, and political will.

Even for these four countries, specific circumstances made it easier than for many others who wished to do this.  Size: three of the four countries are relatively small and culturally homogeneous. Foreign hauliers: all four are heavily traversed by foreign vehicles making cost recovery more urgent. Familiarity: some already had numerous tolled road segments. Industry and Trade: Germany saw that the technology selected for the task might revive its moribund high-tech export industry. No single reason would have sufficed in any of these cases, so hard is the political argument for nation-wide tolling.

Success with wide area urban tolling has been limited to a half-dozen instances: Bergen, London, Milan, Singapore, Stockholm, and Valletta.  Here, too, a number of factors were at play – different in each case. Some combination of bold leadership, political fortune, geo-morphology, severity of congestion, and trust in persuasive reasoning helped put these programs in place.

The good news is that systems such as these ten have been successful in achieving their goals. It is true that the London system – in hind-sight perhaps the least-well executed – has experienced a slide back to earlier congestion levels. But the reasons are understandable and the argument that London would be still worse off without it is worthy.

The bad news is that the expected domino effect of nationwide and urban tolling everywhere shows every sign of late arrival. The UK’s lorry road user charging system and it nationwide road-tolling system has been withdrawn or hobbled – even the majority of its congestion-related transportation innovation fund has been withdrawn, and the new Coalition government has recently provided only a timid promise to “work toward” tolling heavy goods vehicles. Programs from The Netherlands, Sweden, and several other states have been postponed, slowed down or iced.  Maybe the Czechs, French, Poles or Slovenes will pull something off in 2011 or 2012 to keep up our limp, one-every-two-years performance.

A program as difficult and complex as nationwide road user charging requires many circumstances to line up to be put into play. To have sufficient buy-in, you need things such as an affordable and reliable way to measure and collect fees for use, a trusted government, a way to guarantee privacy, a way (and the will) to educate drivers about the problem, politicians that can understand the need (and who are willing to speak out for it), and a set of social policies to address things such as revenue allocation and people made worse off by the change.

Instead of these things, any particular country is more likely to have circumstances such as drivers and journalists being fixated on misinterpreted constructs of entitlement and privacy, a history of government non-transparency re earmarks for fuel-tax revenues that make promises of correct revenue allocation hard to believe, politicians taking a position against to garner votes and a general lack of understanding of road funding and transport economics.

No driver is eager to pay for road-use – including those of us who understand the need for it and the ways to make it respect privacy – and only a minority of people understand that paying by time and place of use rather than with fuel or property taxes sets up pricing signals that can reduce congestion. Fewer still are aware that one dollar of road tolls has the congestion abatement effect of three dollars in fuel taxes – implying that fuel taxes are three times harder on lower income earners than are road tolls, and making transparent road tolls a social improvement over relatively hidden fuel taxes.

In spite of the hurdles, every year hundreds of transport economists study and write about the need for road-pricing and congestion pricing, often without paying tribute to the breadth of these social and political problems much less suggesting how we will overcome barriers to deployment. In the US, since the National Surface Transportation Infrastructure Finance Commission released its report in February 2009, the note of urgency has sharpened, but the discussion in the inner circles has generally been about what kind of trials, or what kind of technology or who among the state DOTs or the Federal government should lead system set up.

Shift in thinking
The cumulative weight of social, political and system complexity is dawning on the community that must solve the combined sustainable mobility problems of road funding, traffic congestion, vehicular emissions and national security (oil independence).  An increasing number of us are seeing that we have no choice but to address this from the driver’s perspective: “what’s in it for me?”

In other words, a direct focus on how to technically and programmatically shift from fuel tax to road-use charging is migrating toward a more nuanced focus on (1) how to gain acceptance and increase the desirability of autonomous telemetrics for fee collection, (2) how to compound the price signals possible from pay-by-use, (3) how to increase government confidence in the reliability, security, and privacy of telematics technology, (4) how enforce the use of such systems cost effectively and while respecting privacy, and (5) how to lower the capital and operational costs of such systems.

This new focus, should it take hold, means that we would consider user-focused market approaches rather than government tax-mandate approaches – at least in the near- to mid-term. Specifically, we would be designing programs for parking payments, pay-as-you-drive insurance, parking finders, green discounts, intelligent safety, navigation and other traveler services to which motorists would voluntarily subscribe in significant numbers because of convenience, savings and rewards. Systems on which road-tolling can depend later.

If this sounds more suited to the consumer design sensibilities of commercial telematics innovators than to tax programming schematics of National Governments or their Departments of Transportation, then how can we best tap into these? After all, there are not yet massive ten-million-subscriber markets for financial transactions for automotive use such as telematics-based parking and insurance payments. If this were to change, then cheap, autonomous road-tolling programs could hitch a ride on the same wireless infrastructure.

Governments could encourage parking reform by eradicating underpriced or free parking in urban areas. National governments could incent regional or urban governments to do this. National, State or Provincial governments could encourage insurance companies to switch to PAYD using a combination of incentives and regulatory change. The creation of markets attracts innovation, investment, and new tax-bases. Such innovation can easily be directed toward telematics-based financial systems for anonymous, autonomous metering systems for parking, insurance and road-use payment systems. Furthermore, such platforms also support safety, navigation and traveler services – things that have been shown to have an attraction for 40-60% of drivers in the EU.  These same systems can accelerate safety and congestion management in the immediate timeframe, all while paving the way to earlier tolling of congestion in urban areas or of certain classes of vehicles such as all electric cars. The bonus is that this approach minimizes the political fallout compared to massive nationwide tolling programming.

If these new markets were liberated and correctly regulated (privacy, fairness, interoperability, transparency, accessibility, etc), a metering and collection system for road-use charging could be built with private money in exact analogy to the way private money developed the current fuel distribution systems on which governments currently depend to collect fuel taxes.

Such programs as I describe may appear circuitous to advocates of the switch from fuel taxes to road use charging.  They are.  But all the evidence to date says that governments cannot go about universal road tolling directly. They need industry help.  But today industry waits for government tenders for trials or for massive tolling systems like the singularities in Germany or Stockholm. Transport ministers complain that driver populations grant no permission for an economic solution to the road funding and traffic congestion problem, but it is also the case that government behaviour in the form of parking and insurance regulation grants no markets to incent solutions.

How long will our transportation ministers and secretaries continue to beat their heads against the road-tolling wall?  How much longer until the lessons of markets and driver services will be used to ease the road to fuel taxation reform?

2010/06/16

UK’s New Coalition and Lorry Tolling

The new UK Government published "The Coalition: our programme for government" containing at section 30 twelve points "to improve the well-being and quality of life" and ' to make the transport sector greener and more sustainable".

A handsome list until you study the language. Eleven of the 12 points use eleven assertive verbs: mandate, grant, reform, make, establish, support, turn, support, commit, stop and tackle. Unfortunately the only point that requires any political courage uses the much safer verb phrase "work towards".  Specifically, "we will work towards the introduction of a new system of HGV road user charging to ensure a fairer arrangement for UK hauliers."

What this means is that they will talk about this with their tails well tucked-in.

Any tolling system costs money to set up and to operate. The history to date is that these systems variously absorb from 20-40% of gross revenues. Since foreign hauliers comprise a slim minority of UK HGVs, they can hardly refund patriated vehicles while charging only foreign vehicles, as is often dangled. With political expediency begging for revenue neutrality, a costly system to collect what is effectively seen as a tax will be unacceptable. The argument that government needs money militates against revenue neutrality and an expensive collection system will destroy any residual appeal.

The Department for Transport, as everyone knows, has been running a set of trials for the past two years that have shown a high degree of both technical and commercial promise for autonomous tolling telematics. As is also becoming increasingly apparent there is no reason for a government to mandate and purchase a dedicated tolling system. Proven telematics technology now permits inexpensive (under £100) units to perform dozens of safety, navigation, parking, traveler and insurance services in addition to tolling management. That makes if possible to have private companies operate profitable services while providing tolling services with little or no capital or operational expense to the taxpayer.

In this circumstance, to deploy a paper vignette system would be absurd and installing a large numbers of DSRC gantries, virtually immoral. The way to do this using private risk capital and 2010 engineering innovation is to set up two to four tolling licenses for the UK and let those for ten-year increments to two to four commercial operators. These operators would be offered a small percentage (3-5%) of tolls collected and left to their own devices to determine competitive services, under reasonable regulations, and to earn a profit.

May the smartest companies do well.

2010/06/01

Leapfrog, Anyone?

It is commonly thought by road-pricing pundits of the nation-wide tolling persuasion that the United States is a decade behind the European Union in readiness to execute. That’s certainly what I thought in 2003, when Minister Alastair Darling was pitching a national road-pricing system in Britain and the London Congestion Charge was still flush with early success.  I no longer think this is true.

Of all the changes since EU optimism has dampened, two stand out.  The EU has canceled, delayed, curtailed or diminished more road-pricing systems and proposals than it has sustained, and the focus has shifted from environmental sustainability (congestion, emissions, livability) to funding.

This sea-change from the benevolent chirps of EU congestion pricing to the grizzly roar of a starving US Highway Trust Fund is decisive. Money speaks louder than livability (even as BP pours oil into the Gulf, anti-tolling newspaper comments from people who can’t make the connection continue apace in Toronto).

This has a couple of implications. The first is that the US is getting serious about national road-pricing and balanced against the EU's halting accomplishments, this has closed the execution gap to 3 or 4 years. I split this shrinkage evenly between the EU's faltering progress and the recent American awakening. While that hardly predicts when a full shift will occur, it says the US may close the gap completely in the next two years.

The second is that a panic-based focus on funding sustainability engenders poor system designs. A "money-now, demand-management-later" criteria leads to solutions that serve to rob us of demand-management tools that transport economists have demanded for 55 years. Every dollar sunk into wrong-focused solutions will cost us ten dollars to undo, later.

As an example, a draft US study in progress currently lists eight charging solutions but only one provides the full tool-set needed to address congestion, funding and emissions, while promoting a shift to EVs. While the well-respected team working on this understands the risks, cash-starved decision-makers acting on the final report may not. We run the risk of politicians selecting an expedient pathway to money, say by reading odometers or tolling only limited access highways that will heavily mortgage our future ability to manage demand. It may even force us into the long-discredited view that we should try to build our way out of congestion.

We should think harder about why and where we are about to leap.

2010/05/02

Four trends will advance the road-tolling agenda in 2010-11

Four trends, in order of importance, will advance the US (and world) road tolling agenda in 2010-11:

ONE:
Funding pressure (e.g., continued Highway Trust Fund bankruptcy) will remain and grow because more and more vehicle miles traveled (VMT) are in higher efficiency vehicles. (This is a US focus due to excessive fuel tax under charging and related political phobia).

TWO:
VMT growth is recovering with the economic recovery, hence the congestion pressure will return: (world focus). Add to this that rising incomes will drive demand for more road capacity (point added by Gabriel Roth).

THREE:
The BP oil-spill disaster will stoke anti-big-car, anti-sprawl, anti-internal-combustion opinion (US and world focus - the disaster will be seen internationally). This will put pressure on electric vehicle delivery and legislators will seek ways to charge user fees to these vehicles as their numbers stop being insignificant.  There is already talk of "starting tolling with electric cars", as it is thought that people who purchase electric vehicles would tend to be more likely to understand how tolling would work and why it is important and fair, as well as understand how privacy can be protected.

FOUR:
The rise of an opt-in metering philosophy to market evolution (Skymeter is a player in bringing this approach to popularity) - this will allow US thinking to catch up to EU thinking, albeit on a parallel path.  EU will switch to an opt-in path (for cars) in 2011, esp as the 2012 deadline for the European Electronic Toll Service (EETS) will pass unmet.  More critically, this will allow the EU to re-focus on cars (they only do trucks so far and the hiccup in the expected Dutch system for all vehicles will permit rethinking toward opt-in (some in Dutch Ministry of Transportation (Rijkswaterstaat) are already saying this, off-record).

I offer a 5th point – more hunch than prediction: Obama will soften toward VMT charging as the oil spill will set back his current off-shore drilling position. His VMT charging position will remain "no", for the next year, running up to the election he will say "we have to look at all options".  After the next election (if he wins re-election) VMT charging will become more than just ITS academics or a subject of time-biding AASHTO studies.